Article Title
Exploring the South-South "Exception" in the World of BITs: The cases of Latin America and India
Abstract
The authors examine the phenomenal proliferation of South-South investment agreements globally, and within Latin America and India in particular. Several studies show that from late 1990s onwards, foreign direct investment flows originating from, and directed towards, developing countries appear to be growing faster than those from developed to developing countries. At the same time, the number of South-South investment agreements being signed and ratified has been growing. The most plausible explanation for the proliferation of North-South agreements, which is that competition among developing countries to attract FDI drives North-South BITs, does not account for this novel development. Taking this analytical gap as their point of departure, the authors tackle the pivotal question of whether the same incentives that underlie North-South investment flows and BITs remain pertinent while analysing South-South interaction. Mainstream explanation for the North-South BITs proliferation - the 'competing-for-capital' theory - does usefully explain the increment in South-South BITs to a significant extent, due to the fact that many developing countries are acquiring the same characteristics as their developed counterparts (for e.g., becoming outward investors). Other South-South investment agreements can be differentiated from North-South ones in the sense that they incorporate development issues, or can be explained as attempts to exploit comparative advantages over Northern investors. Interestingly, the growing disparities and differences between developing countries, which are sometimes as glaring as the gaps between some developed and developing countries, also help in comprehending these trends in international investment regulation. Accordingly, after mooting several possible explanations, the paper takes a closer look at the type of developing countries that engage in South-South investment agreements and separates them according to their income levels. Itis felt that this division helps explain South-South BITs under the same North-South rationale.
Recommended Citation
Bonilla, Stephania and Bernieri, Rosa Castro
(2008)
"Exploring the South-South "Exception" in the World of BITs: The cases of Latin America and India,"
Indian Journal of International Economic Law: Vol. 1, Article 10.
Available at:
https://repository.nls.ac.in/ijiel/vol1/iss1/10